The patient changes the kidney death The hospital judges and compensates 600 000

The patient changes the kidney death The hospital judges and compensates 600,000
The patient changes the kidney death The hospital judges and compensates 600,000
Uremic patient Ms. Du accepts that dies after renal transplantation, relatives query the hospital makes a diagnosis improperly and the kidney source is defective in quality, prosecute hospital of letter of Beijing China and the People's Hospital, Cangzhou, Hebei, claim nearly 900,000 yuan together. The day before yesterday, the reporter learnt, the court of Chaoyang has been already to this case pronouncement of the first instance. Judicial expertise asserts two hospitals have faults, have causality with the death of Ms. Du, adjudicate two hospitals compensate for and amount to more than 600,000 yuan. Woman die after the renal transplantation relative tell, claim 2005, 37 -year-old Ms. Du suffer from uremia, get the intersection of Beijing and the intersection of hospital and treatment, letter of China. Treat its condition steadily through guarding. Later on China's letter hospital claims there is a kidney source in Cangzhou of Hebei, must forward to the locality and do renal transplantation. On September 26 of the same year, Ms. Du transferred to the People's Hospital, Cangzhou. Next day, the doctor and operator of hospital of letter of Beijing China did the pancreas renal transplantation skill. Shut out the women condition to worsen instead after the operation. October 4, Ms. Du accept, transplant the intersection of pancreas and kidney, excise skill, died after all rescue measures proved ineffectual the same day afternoon while being postoperative. Two uniform to have the intersection of fault and relative think two hospitals store in and make a diagnosis improperly hospital, the hospital can't explain the legal source of the kidney source, the quality problem that source of this kidney exists. In addition, the hospital collects " fee of kidney source " of 20,000 yuan Suspected of being involved in the illegal deal organ. So, require two hospitals to compensate death damages, kidney source fee, spirit and conciliate nearly 900,000 yuan such as gold. In the court's trial, China letter hospital show disagree with the intersection of Ms. and demand of family Du, claim kidney source in Cangzhou, consider, get the intersection of Cangzhou and operation just for patient, this with civil to infringe, have nothing to do. In addition, the hospital confiscates " fee of kidney source " too . The People's Hospital, city of Cangzhou, claim this institute operating room and sterilize facilities, accord with the regulation, the operation was done by the personnel of China's letter hospital, this institute should not take on the responsibility. Determine that reveals that there is medical fault that has fault of making a diagnosis to two hospitals, the court trusts the relevant organization to carry on judicial expertise. Expert's conclusion think two hospital have the intersection of operation and way choose enough cautious operating coarse postoperative activity, bleeding, dealing with faulting such as being improper by some operation. The causality of greater intensity exists between these faults and patient's death, propose participating in degree as E grade (theory coefficient is worth 75%, the responsibility intensity is the ultimate liability; It is 60%-90% that compensation consults the range) . The court tries thinking, according to judicial expertise, two hospitals should bear compensation responsibility. Because participate in treating, the responsibility proportion is difficult to divide accurately, two hospitals bear related compensation responsibility each other. Although China's letter hospital denies collecting " The fee of kidney source " ,But not submitted the corresponding evidence, the court adopts the statement of Ms. Du's family of letter. Every compensation number court regards as more than 600,000 yuan. A few days ago, Chaoyang court according to the first instance judgement this, adjudicate two hospital compensate the intersection of Ms. and the intersection of family and every loss more than 600,000 Du for, and bear related compensation responsibility each other. (reporter Chen Bo) Visit The medical organization prohibits accepting " The fee of organ " A medical organization personage introduces, " human organ transplant regulations " implemented in May of 2007 stipulate, the medical organization can't collect the expenses which are transplanted the human organ. But this personage reveals, it is the greatest restriction of an organ transfer operation that the organ source is deficient. Donate to the quantity of the organ and patient waiting for it and differ greatly. Organ illegality is difficult to buy and sell to avoid. The day before yesterday, deputy to the National People's Congress, Wang Wei, secretary of the leading Party members' group of Red Cross Society of China, revealed, plan to set up the information storehouse to realize the organ is donated and connected by information. Will also set up relevant fund and help the organ provider with the difficulty and persons who benefit from. The relevant draft revision has already been referred to the legal system office of the State Council.


|