The patient plucks the massive haemorrhage death of gallbladder Relatives create an uproar in the hospital and claim 8 million

The patient plucks the massive haemorrhage death of gallbladder Relatives create an uproar in the hospital and claim 8 million
The patient plucks the massive haemorrhage death of gallbladder Relatives create an uproar in the hospital and claim 8 million
As an important measure of the medical reform of Hainan Province, are independent of the third party between the hospital, patient and mediate the mechanism - -" medical dispute people's mediation committee of Hainan Province " (are abbreviate as " Medicine of province transfers the committee " )Since the establishment of, already succeeding in mediating and dealing with a batch of history and leaving over fast so far and medical dispute of kainogenesis, among them the largest case at present dealt with compensates the amount of money and reaches 230,000 yuan. Pay a return visit through the case, it reaches 98% to suffer from square satisfaction, has promoted the society to be harmonious effectively. The case understood patient's gallbladder and excised the death of postoperative bleeding in February 11, 2011, what some is the 49 -year-old patient because repeated upper abdomen pains in February to the hospital treatment of one hospital of Qionghai. What some admitted to hospital, it diagnoses to be at that time: Gallbladder calculus. At that time, what some relevant treatment to the ill of checking and resisting infection etc. the school offer. What check, have the intersection of operation and the intersection of taboo and disease and tell surgery unexpected complication that risks might appear in front of the some skill. On February 12, what some carries on IC peritoneoscope gallbladder under general anesthesia and excises the skill. What some takes the drainage tube to leave hospital on February 21. On March 9, what some stills have bile that overflow to pull out the wound of drainage tube, and hospital treatment is observed again. At that time, what some physical condition was: The physical sign of the life is normal, are diagnosed: 1, The gallbladder excises the skill, 2, gallbladder leak. What some comes down with pain on March 19, the companion is uncomfortable in chest and having difficulty in breathing, vomited immediately a large number of blood combined shock symptom, the school, through the whole institute is great holds a consultation to discuss, diagnose as the upper digestive tract bleeds. On March 26, what some passed on and saved one the People's Hospital to rescue, died after all rescue measures proved ineffectual on March 28. Relatives create an uproar in the hospital and hit the doctor and claim 8 million April 28, 2011, what some corpses examine the result to brief on: The gallbladder is excised the postoperative gallbladder bed bleeds and causes the losing blood shock death. What behind the some death, its relative queries: What some is strong, the peritoneoscope gallbladder implementing the general type in this institute excises the skill, people die? Operator and doctor Song because the work is careless, non- responsible, the operation does not pass, the gallbladder cut-outs and sews up technology coarsely, gallbladder be bled bed,before and after in hospital twice,four time subsequent visit, school and last doctor not causing by attentions enough and paying attention to? The condition goes from bad to worse, misdiagnose as gastrorrhagia, cause the gallbladder to excise the postoperative gallbladder bed and bleed and cause the losing blood shock death finally. At that time, what some relatives were attacked, had a nervous breakdown, assembled a crowd, made a scene, enclosed and stopped up the hospital, hinder the administrative personnel of the medical matters from working, even hit this director (this director have to be invited to the hospital for vacation of two weeks) Influence and can't go to work normally seriously. During this time, what some relatives put forward the amount of compensation to school: 8 million yuan. The school think what some 8 million yuan of claim is boasting that medicine of province transfers the committee and mediates to both sides and reaches an agreement many times. Through numerous mediation, doctors and patients both sides still realize difference too big, and patient relatives put forward multiple unreasonable compensation requirements, the opinion of reaching an agreement that unable, patient relatives disagree with continuing mediating. On June 14, medicine of province transfers the younger brother of Qin Gui, director of committee to go to the bureau of justice of Qionghai to mediate live together with mediator. Medicine of province transfers the committee to think: The patient has still too high amount of claim, propose suffering from and then ponder deeply the demand not reasonable, illegal. The intersection of province and medicine transfer the intersection of committee and staff member, hope doctors and patients both parties can until health authority apply, mediate and legal lawsuit come on, safeguard the rights. About one month later, are transferred committee mediator's numerous contact by medicine of province, guide and is persuaded patiently, expound medicine of province transfers characteristic and advantage of the committee, fair, just, it is an independent, specialized third party, dispel the estrangement of both parties of doctors and patients. Both sides reach common understanding finally, require medicine of province to transfer the committee to mediate again. Medicine of province transfers the medical expert of the committee to think: The school has not brought and enough attention's attention to observe the condition after complication appeared, find condition change take effective the intersection of treatment and measure, tertiary to examine, examine, hold a consultation system implement enough in time, should take the main responsibility. Medicine of province transfers the committee mediator and starts the conciliation proceedings, listen to the statements of doctors and patients both parties conscientiously, collect the relevant evidence and do a good job of the investigation of doctors and patients both parties to put down. Pass on the views and opinions of both sides to doctors and patients both parties many times subsequently. Medicine of province transfers the committee and organizes experts, prove in many ways, determine the nature, make the responsibility to this case, decrease definitely, and provide and evaluate the opinion book, through mediating again, is close to the distances of both sides with the medical knowledge, legal principle, doctors and patients both parties reach and mediate the agreement, define the amount of compensation: The school at one time compensates 230000 yuan, doctors and patients both sides agree this responsibility is asserted. The case enlightens a doctor and has not totally tried and made a diagnosis the obligation " compensates 230,000 yuan, mediate the largest medical dispute compensating case of a amount of compensation at present dealt with since medicine of province transferred the committee and is tenable. " Medicine of province transfers committee's your younger brother Qin to tell reporters, view from the point of coming in case of this disease, doctors in charge on duty have not analyzed the cause of disease conscientiously while changing to the operation, not to transfer from one hospital to another in time and cultural and educational care and telling voluntarily that has been deficient. In the activity of making a diagnosis, have not totally tried the obligation of making a diagnosis to correspond with medical level at that time, just cause this medical dispute. Warm to brief on the attentive matters one applied to mediate, accept the telephone Medicine of Hainan Province transfers committee's telephone number: 0898-66533007, 65533009; The telephone number of reporting a case in unison in the whole province: 95500. Second, acceptance range that the people mediated. Besides following situation, so long as the party transfers the committee and can accept and mediate in medicine of Hainan Province by mutual consent: 1, The party has already brought a suit before court; 2,The party has already applied to health authorities, in course of mediating; 3,Both parties consult or are transferred the committee to mediate by medicine, one party goes back on one's word to reach an agreement; 4,Medical dispute caused by practising medicine illegally; 5,Other civil disputations that the non- medical behavior taking place in the medical organization causes. Third, apply for to the people and mediate the material that need to refer to and apply for when the people mediate, suffer from needing to submit just: 1, Mediate the application; 2,The party's ID card original paper and copy; 3,Agent's letter of authority; 4,The agent's ID card original paper and copy; 5,Appeal materials; 6,Relevant evidence material of the dispute. The hospital needs to submit: 1, Mediate the application; 2,Legal representative's letter of authority; 3,Agent's letter of authority; 4,Agent's ID card original paper and copy; 5," operation licence " copy; 6,Handle the situation in dispute; 7,Answering materials in writing to question and requirement which the patient put forward; 8,Relevant evidence material of other disputes. After the medical dispute of procedure that fourth, medical dispute third party mediates takes place, the medical organization notifies and cures and transfers the committee in time to effect an insurance, the mediators of people are Rush for the scene, and notify and compensate to the centre of the place and participate in dealing with. If doctors and patients both sides agree to accept medicine transfers the committee to mediate, both sides fill in " mediate the application form ". Will the people mediators finish the investigating and collecting evidence of medical dispute case within 3 workdays? ぷ's sole  ? According to investigating and forming and mediating the handling suggestion tentatively with material in a workday. Meanwhile, assert tentatively that enters the simple and easy, quick compensating and general compensation processing procedure according to suffering from square amount of claim and case. The key step mediated is: 1, Tell the rights and obligations; 2,Both parties state; 3,The medical expert carries on the technological assessment to the dispute, the law expert puts forward the solution; 4,Mediate; 5,Reach and mediate the agreement. After fifth, the people mediate the performance of the agreement and mediate and reach an agreement, disputed on mediating the performance of the agreement or content of mediating agreement between the parties, one party can bring a suit before people's court. After mediating and reaching an agreement, both parties think the necessary one, can apply for the administration of justice to confirm to the people's court commonly in 30 days from the day of mediating the agreement and coming into force. The party needs law aid and accords with the condition, can transfer the committee work station to put forward and help the application to medicine of province of Law Aid Center. The expert analyzes It is independent of doctors and patients that medicine transfers the committee " The third party " ,Belong to the public beneficial folk corporation, it doesn't collect any expenses to mediate Medicine transfer the intersection of committee and your the intersection of younger brother and the intersection of director and introduction Qin according to Hainan Province, medical the intersection of dispute and people it mediates to be the intersection of people and large important component that mediate. The medical dispute people's mediation committee of Hainan Province is that a trade put on record in the judicial drawing room of Hainan Province, professional people mediate the organization, have stronger professional knowledge and mediate to skill, enthusiastic retired medical expert, judge, public procurator, police officer who mediates undertaking higher, and the lawyer, notary, law worker and mediators of people make up, accept judicial supervision and guidance of administrative department of Hainan Province on the business, it is " the third party " independent of medical organization and patient ,Not under the jurisdiction of any government organ, not even " government organ " . According to the regulation, medicine of Hainan Province transfers the committee and accepts the medical dispute between medical organization and patient of this province, the acceptance range includes the patient, medical organization and medical worker check, problems such as the behavior, consequence, reason, responsibility caused to take place in the course of making a diagnosis, attending to etc., compensating for,etc.. At the time of the dispute producing difference and causing on concept, the main basis of mediating medical dispute in Hainan Province is " law of liability for tort ", " mediate law by people ", " Hainan Province medical dispute prevent from and handle the temporary provisions " laws and regulations, it doesn't collect any expenses to mediate. "Let doctors and patients both sides sit to and resolve the medical dispute through consultation unrealistically calmly, this needs a third party trusting it to talk about a ' justice words ', this is function that medicine transfers the committee. " Qin Gui's younger brother says, at present, the medical dispute is generally solved through three kinds of routes: Medicine transfers committee's mediating, administration's solving, contentious procedure. Qin Gui's younger brother thinks, it is too strong that the administration mediates rigidity, the patient is not easy to accept. And the contentious procedure of going to court and going solves the medical dispute, is usually identified as the case of the malpractice, professional lines is too strong, add much uncertainty on medical science, the lawsuit is very complicated, time consuming and too long, lose a lawsuit and end up so as to the patient, and the lawsuit has been won and does not also get the money sometimes, this is unfavorable to doctors and patients' harmony and social stability. In actual operation, cure and transfer the practical and flexible advantage that the committee has the government and the judicial organization does not possess. Medicine transfers the committee and takes root in the basic unit, presses close to the masses, is familiar with characteristic and advantage of the condition of the people, insist it is rational legal, equal and voluntary and not hindering the principle of party's lawsuit right, can dissolve the medical dispute appropriately, fairly and just in time. (the city newspaper Chen Xin of the southern part of the country)


|